Etsy v Shopify for Print on Demand: Which One is Actually Right For You?

ByJ.B. Updated on
Laptop displaying Etsy v. Shopify comparison on clean desk with plants and colorful sticky notes on wall
This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through one of these links, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read my full disclosure here.

The Etsy v Shopify debate is probably the most common question I get from people who are just starting to figure out print on demand, and I get it. It feels like a big decision. Pick the wrong platform and you could waste months, or money, or both.

Here’s the thing: I have both! An Etsy shop and a Shopify store. I’ve been running print on demand for over three years now, and I can tell you from real, lived experience that comparing these two platforms is not an apples-to-apples situation.

They are genuinely different animals. One is a marketplace. The other is a standalone website. Understanding that one distinction will save you a lot of confusion.

So let’s get into it. I’m going to walk you through both platforms honestly, talk about the fees, the traffic, the learning curve, and what I actually recommend depending on where you are in your journey right now.

What Etsy actually is (and why that matters)

Etsy is a search engine. I know people call it a marketplace, and technically it is, but the way you succeed on Etsy is by treating it like a search engine, the same way you’d think about Google.

People go to Etsy, type in what they’re looking for, and a feed of results comes up. Your job is to make sure your listings show up in that feed.

That one fact changes everything about how you approach selling on Etsy.

Etsy has built-in traffic, which means you don’t have to market your shop to get eyes on your listings.

Etsy is doing email marketing to shoppers. Etsy is running its own ads. Etsy is doing its own social media. You don’t have to do any of that. You don’t have to show your face online.

You don’t have to build a following on TikTok or Instagram before you can start making sales. This is genuinely one of the best things about the platform, especially for beginners who are still figuring out e-commerce and don’t have a marketing background.

This is why Etsy is the ultimate freedom-first starting point. If you want to build a shop that can eventually generate passive income while you’re sleeping, traveling, or just living your life, Etsy gives you that possibility without requiring you to first become a marketing expert.

The one thing you do have to master on Etsy

SEO. That’s it. Search engine optimization, specific to Etsy’s own platform. What that means practically is that you need to figure out what people are actually typing into the Etsy search bar, and then make sure your listing titles and tags reflect those exact phrases.

So many new sellers get frustrated because they have a shop with a few listings and zero views, and they think the platform doesn’t work.

In most cases, the real problem is one of two things: either they have very few listings up (three listings is not enough surface area to get found), or their SEO is off and people simply can’t find them. Both are fixable problems.

Tools like eRank and E-Hunt are what I use to figure out what people are searching for. I use both.

eRank gives you keyword data specific to Etsy, shows you search volume and competition levels, and helps you find niches that are being searched but aren’t completely overrun with listings.

E-Hunt has a Chrome extension I love that lets you see estimated sales numbers on individual Etsy listings while you’re browsing. That kind of competitor research is gold when you’re trying to figure out whether a niche has real demand.

Once you’ve got your SEO dialed in and you’re putting up listings that reflect actual search demand, Etsy starts doing its job. You don’t need to be running ads or posting content constantly to get your first sales. That’s a genuinely rare thing in e-commerce.

And if you’re struggling with finding keywords, or simply don’t have time to do all of the research required, I created The Opportunity Report which is done for you Etsy SEO delivered to you weekly!

The Opportunity Report displayed on multiple devices showing weekly reports, product listings, and business analytics content.

Free for Freedom Unclocked Members

The Opportunity Report

Struggling with finding trends? Get done-for-you Etsy keyword research from a multi six figure seller, delivered weekly.

The Opportunity Report gives you a validated keyword that is selling on Etsy every single week.

Get access for only $9/mo.

Let’s talk about Etsy’s fees

Fees are one of the biggest complaints people have about Etsy, and I’ll be honest, I understand the frustration when you’re first starting out and your margins feel tight.

But I also think the fee conversation misses the bigger picture.

Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee per item, a 6.5% transaction fee on the sale price including shipping, and a payment processing fee that varies slightly by country. When you add it all up, you’re looking at roughly 8-10% of each sale going to Etsy depending on your price point and where you’re shipping to.

That fee is basically the cost of Etsy doing all of your marketing for you, and when you look at it that way, it’s actually a very reasonable trade.

Scrabble tiles arranged to spell 'Online Shop' on marble background for an e-commerce concept.

If you had a Shopify store, you’d be paying for ads to drive traffic to it. Facebook ads are an added expense that you have to budget for each month. And, if you don’t know how to run those ads, it is an expensive thing to learn.

When you stack up the real cost of running Facebook ads versus paying Etsy’s transaction fees on sales you’re already making, Etsy starts to look pretty reasonable. The fees only feel painful if you’re not pricing your products correctly, which is a separate conversation worth having.

If you want a deep dive on how to price your POD products so that Etsy’s fees don’t eat your margins, I laid it all out in this article.

What Shopify actually is

Shopify is your own website. That’s the core of it. You pay a monthly subscription, you build out your store using a theme, you connect it to Printify just like you would with Etsy, and then you have your own branded shop on the internet.

The key word there is “on the internet.” Because Shopify is not a marketplace.

Nobody goes to Shopify.com and types in “funny mom sweatshirt” and finds your store. Your store exists at its own URL, and people only get there if you send them there.

This is probably the most important distinction in the Etsy v Shopify debate.

You have to drive your own traffic on Shopify

This is the biggest difference between Etsy and Shopify, and it’s the one that trips people up the most.

On Etsy, traffic comes to you. On Shopify, you go get traffic. Those are two very different skill sets.

The main ways people drive traffic to a Shopify store are SEO for Google and other search engines, paid ads (usually Facebook, Tik Tok, Pinterest or Google), and their own existing audience, like an email list or a Facebook group.

Each of those takes time, money, or both to build.

Google SEO for a new Shopify store can take six months to a year before you start seeing meaningful organic traffic. Google has to index your site, crawl it, and decide it’s worth showing to searchers.

And even then, there are other factors that determine whether you will rank in the search like your domain authority, which is 1 when you first open up shop.

That’s a long runway if you need sales now. Paid ads can work faster, but you need to know what you’re doing. Running Facebook ads without a real understanding of targeting, creative testing, and budget management is a fast way to burn through money with nothing to show for it.

If you already have an audience, a Facebook group, or an email list, Shopify makes a lot of sense right now. If you don’t, Etsy is your fastest path to your first sale.

The real costs of running a Shopify store

The Shopify subscription starts at around $39 a month for the basic plan. That’s just the base.

Once you start building out your store, you’ll likely need apps.

  • There’s a shipping tracking app so customers can see when their order will arrive.
  • An email marketing platform like Brevo or Klayvio to collect and email your list.
  • An affiliate app if you want to build a referral program.
  • Possibly a review app, an upsell app, or a custom theme that costs extra.

It adds up.

My monthly Shopify overhead right now includes the subscription, a few apps, and my Facebook ad budget of around $300 a month.

That’s a real cost you have to be prepared to cover before you’re profitable. When you’re just starting out and haven’t validated what sells, that’s a meaningful risk.

Etsy, by comparison, has a very low cost of entry. You pay $0.20 per listing and then transaction fees only when you actually sell something. You’re not paying for marketing that may or may not work. You’re paying a percentage of revenue you’ve already earned.

The ownership question: who actually owns your customers?

This is where Shopify has a real, concrete advantage that goes beyond just fees and traffic.

On Etsy, the customers are Etsy’s customers. They came to Etsy, they found your listing, they bought your product. But Etsy owns that relationship.

You can’t take those buyer emails and add them to your own list. You can’t message them directly outside of Etsy’s messaging system.

If Etsy suspends your shop tomorrow for any reason, you lose access to that entire customer history.

That’s a real risk, and anyone who’s been on Etsy for a while knows that account suspensions happen, sometimes for things that feel arbitrary.

On Shopify, the customer is yours. Their email address is in your system. You can follow up with them, offer them a discount on their next order, invite them into a loyalty program, run a win-back campaign six months later. That relationship compounds over time in a way that Etsy simply doesn’t allow.

When you build a Shopify store with a real customer base, you also have something that has actual sale value.

Shopify stores can be sold. Etsy shops, because the customers belong to Etsy, cannot be sold. If your long-term goal is to build something you can eventually sell, or to create a real brand with repeat buyers, Shopify gives you a path there that Etsy doesn’t.

Laptop showcasing fashion e-commerce site alongside shopping bags, ideal for online shopping themes.

How to use both platforms together (this is what I actually did)

Here’s my honest recommendation, and it’s exactly what I did when I was building my shop from scratch.

Start on Etsy. Get comfortable with e-commerce. Learn how to research niches, how to write titles and tags that actually get found, how to use Printify or another POD supplier to produce and ship your products automatically.

Get your first sales. Figure out what people like. Let Etsy’s marketplace tell you what’s actually in demand.

That last part is huge. Etsy is essentially a free focus group. You can put up 50 listings in different niches and see what gets views, what gets favorites, and what actually converts into sales. You don’t have to guess what people want. The data shows you.

Once you have consistent sales on Etsy and you know which products are performing, that’s when you bring those winning products over to Shopify.

You already know people want them. You’ve already tested the designs. Now you’re not running blind with your ad budget, you’re putting money behind products that have a proven track record.

Etsy validated my niche. Shopify gave me a way to own it and scale it.

When I set up my Shopify store, I moved over everything that was consistently selling on Etsy. Then I started learning Facebook ads with those validated products.

That’s a much smarter way to spend your ad budget than throwing money at something you haven’t tested yet.

Using both platforms in parallel also means you’re not dependent on one income stream. If Etsy has a slow month, Shopify might be doing well. If your Facebook ads are eating into margin, your Etsy passive income is still coming in.

That kind of diversification is real financial stability.

The learning curve is real on both sides

I want to be straight with you: neither platform is completely hands-off. Etsy requires you to learn its SEO, understand what’s in demand, and stay on top of changes to the platform.

Shopify requires you to learn how to build a converting storefront, manage apps and integrations, and drive traffic through ads or organic channels.

But the learning curves are different in kind. Etsy’s learning curve is more contained. You learn one thing, SEO, and it starts paying off relatively quickly once you have enough listings up.

Shopify’s learning curve is broader. You’re learning web design basics, conversion optimization, email marketing, and paid advertising, often all at the same time.

That’s not a reason to avoid Shopify forever. It’s a reason to sequence things correctly.

Get the foundation built on Etsy first. Make money while you learn. Then bring that money and that knowledge into Shopify when you’re ready to grow.

If you want a structured way to learn the Etsy side first, Freedom Unclocked is the course I built specifically for this. It covers niche research, SEO, design creation with AI tools, and how to set up your shop for long-term passive income. It’s the foundation I wish I’d had when I was starting out.

laptop mockup with etsy course freedom unclocked

Freedom Unclocked

Ready to build an Etsy POD shop with a strategy that actually works?

The Freedom Unclocked Membership is a complete Etsy POD course, the exact method I used to grow my shop to multi-six figures, plus live group coaching and a community doing the work alongside you.

join today!

A quick word on design tools and costs

One thing that has changed a lot in the past couple of years is what it costs to create good designs for your POD products.

When I started in 2022, I was buying mockups constantly, spending real money to get my listings looking good. Now, AI tools have completely changed that math.

Ideogram is one I use regularly for generating design graphics with text, especially for quote-based products. Ideogram’s text rendering is unusually accurate for an AI tool, which matters a lot when you’re making something like a typography sweatshirt or a custom mug. I also use Ideogram for creating mockups, which saves me from having to buy mockup packs.

Canva is still my everyday tool for editing designs, creating graphics, and putting together product mockups. The amount it’s improved since 2022 is honestly wild. It’s where I spend most of my design time.

The point is: your actual operating costs for an Etsy POD shop can be kept pretty low. A design tool subscription, an SEO tool subscription, and your Printify account.

That’s your core stack. You’re not paying for inventory, you’re not paying for shipping supplies, and you’re not paying for ads.

That’s what makes Etsy such a strong starting point for building a freedom-first business.

Final Thoughts

The Etsy vs Shopify question doesn’t have a single right answer, but it does have the right sequence for most people. Start with Etsy because the barrier to entry is low, the learning curve is focused, and the traffic is built in.

Use it to learn what actually sells, nail your niche, and build consistent income. Then take that knowledge and those winning products into Shopify when you’re ready to own your customer base and scale with paid traffic.

You don’t have to choose one forever. The best version of this business runs on both.

If you’re still trying to figure out whether your current Etsy shop is set up correctly, start with the Self-Audit Cheat Sheet. It’s free and it’ll show you exactly where your shop needs work. And if you want the full roadmap from zero to consistent Etsy sales, Freedom Unclocked is where to go next.

You’ve got this. The platform stuff is learnable. The real work is just getting started and staying consistent long enough to let the data teach you.

The Best SEO and Design Tools for Your Print on Demand Shop:

These are the only tools I use for my shop!

Canva: Canva is the most amazing tool. It is user friendly, and always improving! The tools that Canva has have evolved so much since I first started using it in 2022 for the better. I use it almost everyday. I use it to create designs, to edit AI designs, and to create product mockups.

Ideogram: Ideogram is an AI design tool that generates high-quality graphics with exceptionally accurate text rendering, making it ideal for creating quote-based and typography-focused designs. I also use the prompt based editing for mockups, making it a wonderful alternative to Photoshop, which is expensive.

E-Hunt: E-Hunt is fantastic for competitor research and some light keyword research. My favorite aspect of E-Hunt is the Chrome extension that allows you to see the sales amount for an individual item on Etsy. Check out this article to see an example.

eRank: eRank is an SEO data tool that also allows you to search the competition and will also give you key words for your Etsy listing. It is also a low cost tool that will help you find low competition and highly searched niches.

Printify: Printify is a print-on-demand (POD) service that allows individuals and businesses to create and sell custom-designed products without needing to manage inventory or handle fulfillment. I put my designs on products offered by Printify. When an item sells, Printify prints and ships to my customer.

Vela: Vela is the bulk editing tool I use to manage hundreds of Etsy and Shopify listings without losing my mind. You can update videos, photos, titles, tags, descriptions, and prices across your entire shop in minutes, and your VA can build listings inside Vela without needing your Etsy login. Read more about Vela here.

Shopify: Shopify is what I recommend when you are ready to scale beyond Etsy and diversify where your products sell. The fees are lower, you own your customer data (emails), and it integrates directly with Printify and Vela. It is the easiest way to build a standalone storefront that you control. Read more about Etsy v Shopify here.

FAIRE: FAIRE is the wholesale marketplace I use to sell my products to retail, brick and mortar stores. If you want to scale your shop and add a wholesale revenue stream to your POD business, FAIRE is a great option. Read more about FAIRE here.

📌Share on Pinterest

Etsy vs Shopify for print on demand comparison guide - which platform builds passive income faster infographic

Looking for more information on print on demand? Check out these articles:

Janeen is a former attorney and Etsy print on demand coach who started her shop at 40, retired early from corporate life at 42, and moved her family to Portugal. She now teaches others the strategic path to building portable income, while exploring and documenting the most beautiful country she gets to call home.